Written/Reviewed By:
Barry S. Kantrowitz, Esq.Last Updated: Nov 20, 2026
Read Time: 5 mins

Medical bills after a New Jersey car crash can go unpaid when the injured person’s own insurer delays, denies, or cuts back a payment. The no-fault statute gives the injured person a set path for challenging that decision.
Payment timing follows written notice
Under N.J.S.A. 39:6A-5 personal injury protection benefits become overdue if they aren’t paid within 60 days after the insurer receives written notice of the claim. The insurer can avoid that result by denying the claim or by requesting additional time to investigate within that period.
Interest runs on overdue payments. The rate is the one set by the court rules, so an unpaid claim carries a cost for the insurer.
An injured driver who isn’t sure when written notice went out can ask an Englewood car accident lawyer to reconstruct the dates from the claim file and the insurer’s letters. Those dates determine whether a payment is overdue, and they also fix when the insurer’s investigation period began and ended.
A dispute can go to dispute resolution
Under N.J.S.A. 39:6A-5.1 a dispute over personal injury protection or medical expense benefits may be submitted to dispute resolution on the initiative of any party to the dispute. The decision must be in writing, identify the issues, state its findings, carry the signature of the dispute resolution professional, and bind the parties.
The no-fault statute separately requires insurers to give a claimant the option of submitting a dispute to that process, so the choice doesn’t depend on the insurer’s goodwill. The commissioner writes the rules for how these proceedings are conducted, and compensation for the professionals who decide them can’t be paid on a contingency basis.
Records should be gathered before a dispute starts
A claim is argued from dated records rather than recollection. Providers, insurers, and the injured person each hold part of the file, so gathering the pieces takes time.
These documents should be gathered before a dispute begins:
- Bills and treatment records from every provider show the care that was received.
- The insurer’s denial or reduction letter states the reason given for the decision.
- Proof of mailing shows the date each written notice went out.
- The declarations page identifies the coverage limits and the policy period.
Steps taken right after a collision, such as reporting the crash promptly, create the paper record that a later payment dispute depends on. Gaps in the file are simpler to fill while the investigation period is still open.
Payment disputes sit beside other questions
A payment dispute is its own question, and the section that governs payment timing doesn’t mention the lawsuit threshold a driver selected. Keeping the two apart stops a billing disagreement from being mistaken for a lawsuit question.
Photographs, the police report, and the first treatment notes all carry dates, and each date can matter if the insurer’s timeline is questioned later. A timeline that matches the insurer’s own letters leaves little room for argument over when a payment came due.
Related claims depend on the same file
A payment dispute that grows into a lawsuit becomes part of an Englewood personal injury claim, where the same treatment records support the damages case. The insurer’s letters then become part of the evidence.
The insurer’s correspondence records when each payment was requested and how the insurer answered. Comparing them with treatment dates shows where payment and care fell out of step.
A collision elsewhere in the county produces the same insurer letters and claim dates, and they enter a Bergen County personal injury claim as the record of how the medical bills were handled. The paperwork and the dates printed on it stay the same whichever town in the county the crash occurred in.
Pedestrians, motorcyclists, and passengers hurt in New Jersey car accident claims also have medical bills to document, and a denial letter from any insurer belongs in the same file. Each would use the letter’s date to measure the insurer’s response time.
The claim file keeps the timeline
Kate Carballo focuses on personal injury and medical malpractice and obtained a $795,000 jury verdict for a 32-year-old musician injured in an auto accident after the insurance company offered only $6,000. She is a partner at Kantrowitz, Goldhamer, Graifman, Perlmutter & Carballo, P.C., our firm, and the firm has 51 years of experience.
A dated record of every notice and every response lets the dispute begin from facts. The record also shows how long each payment has been outstanding.
Anyone whose medical bills have gone unpaid after a crash can get in touch with an Englewood car accident lawyer to review the insurer’s letters and the claim dates. Sorting out the timeline early shows which letters are still missing.
Get in Touch
"*" indicates required fields